Sunday, May 19, 2013

PAAE: It's over! Max finds happiness and all is right with the world ... maybe

Continue discussion from prior class
  • B block: we talked about Max seeing Rose/Max seeing Sister; need to address — Max seeing father; Max seeing himself; How do others see Max?
  • F block: have yet to discuss any groups' work

Final Discussion
  • p. 220, Daniel says, "Let us never speak of this again." What does Daniel want to forget? Think literally and figuratively.
  • p. 225: "And so my father's picture joined the other images in the lost museum of my mind."
  • p. 227: "The will told me Rose was most likely in Paris, and I felt a vague unpleasant anger toward the dead. How often had my father been in contact with her during my decades of faithful silence? With what knowledge had he died."
  • p. 231: "Did this mean that a son's love and grief for his father triumphed over all? Or that, in a moment of reckoning, I had seen and remembered nothing? I understood then that Rose had begun to bid only once I had stopped. She had been sent to Drouot's, or went of her own accord, in case I had forgotten what I would see there."
  • p. 231: "The shimmering of the city was also part of the canvas: Matisse's lemons seemed to float above the table and the white plate on which they might have rested, if they had been given rest. It was a still life that had not been granted stillness. I thought of the dimensions of the painting, of its flat and hovering planes, and that somewhere, in between the two, lingered those whom I had lost."
Slides
37: This is the deportation list from the Nazi files where Bertrands family is listed---He is number 887. From the Holocaust archives in Paris. Page 212.
38: Page 222
39: Matisses Interiuer Jaune et Vert: page 230
40: L-R: Omar Bradley, General Patton, and Eisenhower in salt mine, examining looted artwork.  Page 236.
41: Entartete Kunst Exhibit page 237
42: Lucerne, Switzerland: Auction of degenerate German art from before the war. Page 237.
43: Van Gogh auctioned at Lucerne auction page 237
44: Picassos Absinthe Drinker, auctioned in Lucerne: page 237

Tuesday, May 14, 2013

PAAE: 176-203

Lost Art and Today!

Some slides
  • 18: Rue Pavee synagogue, where Max meets Chaim. In the Marais, the traditionally Jewish district of Paris.  Page 107.
  • 19: Only known picture of the Velodrome dHiver roundup or rafle (in French). Biggest roundup of French Jewry. Page 114.
  • 20: Maurice Chevalier, in his famous hat--page 129
  • 21: Song
  • 22: Drancy Internment camp, where Jews were imprisoned in horrible conditions before being deported to concentration camps.  Very close to central Paris.  Page 131.
  • 23: Auschwitz--Train Tracks--page 131
  • 24: Delacroixs _Jacob Wrestling with the Angel_ in the Saint Suplice Church--page 139
  • 25: Jeu de Paume, today: page 148
  • 26: Vermeers Astronomer - looted from the Rothschild familys collection during ww2--one of the 1st paintings Hitler looted for his own collection--page 152
  • 27: Rose's street p. 153
  • 28: Goering @ Jeu de Paume, examining a Corot (note bottle of champagne in the background)-- page 153
  • 29: Tolbiac warehouse, inspected by Kurt von Behr (in uniform, on right) and Alfred Rosenberg (in trenchcoat, on left).  Jewish prisoners stand behind the crates of stolen Jewish goods.  Page 156.
  • 30: Salle des Maryrs in Jeu de Paume--page 157
  • 31: Page 157
  • 32: Page 157
  • 33: Goering--Hitlers #2, head of the Luftwaffe (air force) and voracious looter of artwork. Page 170.
  • 34: The inspiration for Rose Clement--Rose Valland page 171
  • 35: The inspiration for Rose Clement (Rose Valland, in her uniform): page 171
  • 36: Rose Vallands notes from during the war.  See the word Rembrandt in the upper left-hand corner.  Page 171
Discussion
1. Different views:
Group 1 is Max seeing his father (4)
How does Max see his father throughout the novel? What has he learned about his father? How has his image of him changed? From whom does he learn about his father's life? Find textual evidence to support your answers.

Group 2 is Max seeing Rose (4)
How does Rose see Max throughout the novel? Find textual evidence to support your answers.

Group 3 is Max seeing himself (4)
How does Max define himself throughout the novel? Find textual evidence to support your answers.

Group 4 is others seeing Max (3)
This novel is told through Max's perspective, but how does Max perceive others' perception of him?

Group 5 is Max seeing his sister (3)
Micheline is in the novel from the beginning. How does Max see her? Learn about her? Perceive her?

Friday, May 10, 2013

Journal Entry #2


Guidelines for Journal Entry Submission

At the top of every journal entry, please include your character's name, age, gender and role in war.

File NameName_Journal2.pdf (please save the file as a PDF)

Where to drop itDropItToMe.Com/mcollie

Password: EnglishRocks

Due by the end of class.

Tuesday, May 7, 2013

PAAE: 148-175


Free write: "Her every belonging, Madam van Seyveld said, has been replaced by something that resembled its predecessor but was fundamentally different" (123). This same sentiment was shared by many people after the war. We can even see this happening to Max as he is trying to replace Rose/their relationship and his father's paintings.

Option 1: Think about your character for the scrapbook project and write about something that was replaced in their lives with a similar yet "fundamentally different" item.

Option 2: Think about your own life and write about how something was replaced with something similar but "fundamentally different."


Discussion
** Let's look at some slides, first (up to 36)
1. In what ways is Chaim's refusal to have his passport stamped "Deporté" a sign of his struggle with identity, a struggle with its dynamics and what define him?
2. p. 124: the resourcefulness of the art dealers (I love this story!)
3. p. 129: Chevalier's "Valentine"
4. What does Sara contrast of Chaim and Max's war time experiences on p. 131?
5. In what ways has Max receded from the foreground of the action?
6. Exactly what did Rose do during the water (p. 148-152, 158, 170-175)?
7. Do you think Max needs Rose or wants Rose? Justify your response.
8. Recovery of one painting ... p. 162
9. Dream p. 165
10. Rose's rebuttal: p. 169

**How has Max's voice changed over the course of the novel thus far? How would you describehis voice in Parts 1 & 2? Part 3?

Monday, May 6, 2013

Journal Entry #1

Guidelines for Journal Entry Submission

At the top of every journal entry, please include your character's name, age, gender and role in war.

File Name: Name_Journal1.pdf (please save the file as a PDF)

Where to drop it: DropItToMe.Com/mcollie

Password: EnglishRocks

Due by the end of class.