1. Check responses & vocab
2. Discussion questions:
*How does the apparition of the banquet affect Alonso and his entourage?
*How is the banquet used as a symbol?
*Why aren’t the men allowed to eat the food? Is this an effective moment for Ariel to accuse them of their sins?
Quiz time! You'll be fabulous.
Homework questions. Answer one of the following:
| 1. How is Ferdinand different from Caliban in his relationship to Miranda? Why does he pledge to keep her honor safe? OR 2. What is the overall impact of the Masque? How is it supposed to affect the two young lovers? What is its message about the sanctity of the marriage bond? |
35 comments:
The Masque was supposed to be a little trick to gain a little power over Miranda and Ferdinand. But I think that the masque amazes them and confuses them and after the abrupt end they figure out he has been acting a little weird. They are so amazed Ferdinand even calls it a “Majestic vision,” (4.1.118) which also implies that he can tell that it is not real (may be a misinterpretation and he’s really just saying he can see it). Also adding on to the suspension on (4.1.119-120) Ferdinand says, “May I be bold to think these spirits?” or in modern English “Would I be correct to think these are spirits,” He also proclaims that he would love to live there for the rest of his life (4.1.120-122). I also think that this play and many others of Shakespeare show that no matter how underground it is you must be blessed and or have a marriage and not just run off together. I think it also shows that if it is not sacred it won’t work out like in Much Ado About Nothing When the main character thinks his bride to be is “unpurified” they almost call the whole thing off.
-BKWJr
While Caliban’s relationship with Miranda consists of Caliban serving and protecting Miranda, Ferdinand’s relationship with Miranda is based on dependence and compassion. Miranda never considered Caliban to be a romantic person whom she wanted to marry. Ferdinand’s appearance was unexpected and he was not placed under a father label, like Prospero, and her father put Caliban under a servant tag. Therefore, Miranda’s relationship with Ferdinand is the first one where she has the freedom to decide what direction she would like it to go in. Though Ferdinand has had to prove himself to Prospero with labor, he did not have to prove himself to Miranda. In Caliban’s case, he must prove himself to Miranda, but will never be successful because Prospero does not approve, and has already nurtured Miranda with the idea that Caliban is not worthy of their respect. Ferdinand pledges to keep her honor safe for two reasons. The first reason is to meet Prospero’s demands, because Ferdinand is aware that the minute Prospero is unhappy, the union will disappear. In addition, Ferdinand wishes that Miranda keeps her naïve and innocent character, and vows to protect her. However, Miranda will reciprocate this act of protecting, whereas Caliban can repeatedly help Miranda, without thanks or love as a reward. -JuPi
Calibans relationship with Miranda is purely a friend to a servant type of connection. While on the other hand Ferdinand has a true love and passion to be with Miranda. Caliban wishes that if he were king that he would be able to get with all of the women. Caliban wants to be with a women out of a desire for power. While Ferdinand is able to experience the true feeling of love and he desires to be with Miranda because he truly loves her.
The General/The Point Guard
Both Ferdinand and Caliban have a thing for Miranda, but the type of thing is different. Ferdinand's love is stronger, or at least he thinks his love is strong. In reality, Prospero has cast a spell over him to fall in love deeply with Miranda. Caliban's infatuation is real, but he sort of thinks of her as something nice that he would want to be able to call his own. While Ferdinand describes her personality, Caliban thinks more about her physical beauty.
Ferdinand promises to keep Miranda's honor safe because Prospero tells him that their marriage will be miserable if he doesn't, and like the rest of the people on the island, he is under Prospero's control.
-Ebay
Ferdinand is deeply in love with Miranda and respects her greatly. Because of this, he vows to keep her honor safe. He is essentially proving, to both Prospero and Miranda, that no matter what, he will protect Miranda and honor her wishes and innocence. Calliban on the other had is the equivalent the creepy guy who is only attracted to miranda physically, if at all. His love for her is obviously not very deep or serious, as he is planning to kill her father, whom she is so close with. The main difference between the two is that Ferdinand is thinking only of Miranda and what he can do to support her, honor her, and make her happy, while Calliban is, as usual, only thinking of himself and what would make him happy. I can imagine him thinking of miranda as just a toy and not as a human being with feelings.
-Bolivia
Caliban and Ferdinand both have very different relationships with Miranda. Her connection with Caliban is more of a master servant relationship. She and Ferdinand, on the other hand, are truly in love and have a stronger relationship. One of the reasons that Miranda's relationship with Caliban is so unstable is that he tried to violate her (1.1.347-348). He attempted to do this before the play even started, which leads me to believe that Miranda was younger at the time, and was probably mentally scared. Ferdinand, however, pledges to protect Miranda's virginity until they are officially married. He does this because, "The white cold virgin snow upon my heart abates the ardour of my liver," (4.1.55-56). Ferdinand says that his love for Miranda is so pure that he would never dream of "destroying her virgin-knot," (4.1.15) before the matrimonial ceremony was completed. Another reason that he swears to protect her honor is that Prospero is a pretty intimidating person, and he threatened their marriage should Ferdinand decide to jump the gun.
-Simba
Ferdinand is different from Caliban in his relationship to Miranda by having a stronger love for Miranda than Caliban. Prospero has cast a spell upon Ferdinand to make him fall in love with Miranda. With the spell Ferdinand is in deep love with Miranda and he promises to keep her honor safe. He wants to make her happy and make their relationship work. Caliban has no spell set against him, so his love is kinda real. Caliban is only into her looks unlike Ferdinand who is more into her personality.
Rizzuti
Ferdinand is deeply in love with Miranda and what he thinks is fate is really magic. Caliban only likes Miranda a little. Ferdinand cannot stop thinking of Miranda and will do whatever is best for her. Caliban on the other hand thinks that claiming Miranda would be nice but not marvelous. Ferdinand and Caliban love Miranda on different levels. Ferdinand is much more intense while Caliban has not shown much affection and could care less. Caliban is willing to give her to Stephano as a reward for the execution of Prospero. Caliban values power over Miranda, Ferdinand values Miranda over power.
Ferdinand pledges to keep her honor safe because he thinks their unity is destiny and their love is true. He does not need lust to make it stronger. He also wants a good word from her father. If he does not consent to this agreement, he is not allowed to call Miranda his.
KChang
The overall impact of the masque was to have more control over Miranda and Ferdinand love. Also i think the masque was created in order to build a stronger relationship between Miranda and Ferdinand. The masque is supposed to affect the lovers by in a way helping them lead the best lives as possible. I think the message of the sanctity of a marriage bond is marriage is a sacred art,and is special and unique. Also i think that marriage is something that precious, and fragile. In my opinion i think thats the reason why Propsero is taking so much time with their union. it's because when the two marry he wants it to be as strong as possible.
-Grubbies
Although it seems that Ferdinand is the one who truly “owns” Miranda in terms of love, Caliban seems to think that he also has a chance with her. Ferdinand expresses a much more loving admiration for Miranda than Caliban does. Due to the fact that Prospero has cast a spell on Ferdinand, Ferdinand is able to spend much more time with her, and truly interact with her. I think that it is really hard for Caliban to show his admirations for Miranda when he is the slave to Miranda’s father. It would not only be a bit awkward for Caliban if he tried to be lovers with Miranda, but I also think that it would make Prospero very ticked off.
Ferdinand pledges to keep Miranda’s honor safe out of fear. Prospero warned him, that if Ferdinand didn’t keep her honor safe, that their marriage would be living hell for Ferdinand. It will be interesting to see what happens if Ferdinand is ever released from the spell, and discovers all of the shady thing that Prospero has used against him.
E$
Ferdinand and Caliban’s relationship with Miranda are completely different. As Bolivia said, Caliban is attracted to Miranda physically, but he works for Miranda so their relationship on the personal and emotional side is non-existent and will never be as he is planning on killing Prospero, Miranda’s father. As for Ferdinand he, at first, was attracted solely on physical attraction, but Miranda and his relationship has developed and matured on a deeper and more meaningful understanding.
Ferdinand has pledged to keep her honor safe, for he believes that they’re love is so great that he can wait. But mostly because Prospero has requested that they wait until marriage, and Ferdinand must respect this, for he is under Prospero’s control.
-JuRo
Miranda's relationship with Ferdinand is nothing like her relationship with Caliban. Caliban never really liked her; he just saw her as a kind of opportunity. "Thou didst prevent me-I had peopled else this island with Calibans." (1.2,349-350) But Ferdinand actually loves Miranda, or is convinced he loves her. Miranda's present relationship with Caliban is not a pleasant one. He is her servant, but she doesn't like him at all. Ferdinand she loves.
By keeping her honor safe, Ferdinand is proving to Prospero that he will take care of Miranda and that he is a good guy. He is saying that he can keep a promise, and that he respects Prospero. He is also proving to Miranda that he loves her for who she is, not for what she is.
Kupkake
Ferdinand is different than Caliban in his relationship with Miranda because Ferdinand is viewed as equal, while Caliban is inferior. The difference in the hierarchy is evident when the two men are being addressed. Miranda admires and speaks positively to Ferdinand, but Caliban is treated poorly and as a servant. Ferdinand pledges to keep her honor because he values the importance of love and wishes to retain the approval of Prospero.
Kevin
Ferdinand and Miranda's love was based primarily off of physical attraction, Caliban and Miranda's relationship didn't have the chance of that. This most likely means that their relationship was built more on compatible interests and personality traits. Another difference is that in Miranda's relationship with Caliban, they were both providing for each other: Miranda taught Caliban, and Caliban did chores for Miranda. However, in Miranda's relationship with Ferdinand, she is completely relying on him, playing into a male stereotype which makes me question how long this relationship will last. Ferdinand promises to keep her honor safe, because he believes she is worth it, and Prospero says that is the only way their marriage will last.
Grace Donahoe
Ferdinand's relationship with Miranda is completely different than Caliban's relationship with Miranda. Within minutes of meeting each other, Miranda and Ferdinand fall in love. Caliban and Miranda have lived on the island together for years and never had a strong romantic connection. Ferdinand loves Miranda in an romantic way and loves her, not the idea of having her or any other woman. Caliban however doesn't love Miranda in such a romantic way but he likes the idea of having a woman and having power over someone or something. In addition, he believes being with Miranda will bring him power.
Ferdinand pledges to keep Miranda's honor safe because he believes that their love is strong enough to wait until after they are married. By doing this Ferdinand is once again proving that he is truly in love with Miranda. In addition, Prospero believes that they should wait and Ferdinand wants to win Prospero's approval.
-Finewoman
Miranda has very different relationships with Ferdinand and Caliban. Miranda and Ferdinand share a special bond, whether it is based off of magic or not. It was love at first sight for them, and they are going to get married. He promises Prospero to keep her honor safe because he loves her, and he cares about her. Even though Prospero did add a little magic to their relationship, there is still love there. With Miranda and Caliban, he is merely attracted to her physically. There is no real connection between them. Caliban has been Miranda’s servant for many years, and as E$ said, it would be awkward for them to be lovers. Caliban also is only really interested in Miranda to gain power, whereas Ferdinand and Miranda love each other.
-LIL LITTLE
Question 2- The masque made the marriage of Miranda and Ferdinand undoutful. Neither of them would be able to question reality. I think it also made Ferdinand really believe in himself and have no questioning thoughts on what he was doing. The masque also helped Prospero make the couples love even stronger. Ferdinand exclaims "let me live here ever. So rare a wonder'd father and a wife makes this place paradise.(4.1.123)" This shows how the masque really did work to the affect Prospero intended. Ferdinand loves his wife, his step father and the island and wants to live there for the rest of his life. The confirmation of their marriage is important especially to Prospero who seems to wish them to have a long and happy marriage. Although their love is fake Prospero wants it to be strong.
-Lotte Off
The Masque was a time for Ferdinand and Miranda to be both congratulated and blessed for their upcoming wedding and also to be warned that their marriage should be made of love, not lust. Prospero first states this idea just before the Masque: “Be more abstemious, or else good night your vow” (4,1.53-54). This is warning the two lovers that if they show too much affection for each other Prospero will cancel the wedding and take away his blessings. The Masque puts this idea deeper in Ferdinand and Miranda’s minds when the gods Ceres and Juno bless the couple’s wedding. Before blessing the lovers Ceres inquires: “Tell me, heavenly bow, if Venus or her son, as thou dost know, do now attend the queen?” (4,1. 86-88). Ceres is saying that if the goddess of love, Venus, has interfered with this couple’s love, she will take away her blessings. Ceres is blessing a couple whose relationship is full of love and not of lust. The Masque both pleases and humbles Ferdinand and Miranda. With these blessings, they will live long, peaceful lives filled with love. However, they are also warned that if they are not “abstemious” (4,1. 54) their love and future will endure many hardships. I think that the entire Masque was trying to emphasize the point that there must be a deep feeling of affection and care in a relationship. If there is only lust, the relationship will not work out.
-TKD Kid
Ferdinand and Miranda perceive the masque as a celebration and Prospero’s validation of their union and love. Prospero’s intentions, however, are slightly more manipulative. He approves of their marriage, but as soon as he leaves the island to inevitably go to Naples, his superiority is left behind. Prospero enjoys his power, and is not quick to abandon it. The celebration with Ceres, Iris, and Juno is used to awe Ferdinand into insisting they stay on the island and relish in its wonders. Ferdinand pleads to forever on the island with Miranda as his bride and Prospero as his father, and Prospero makes no objection.
- Irish Maiden
The main differences in Miranda's relationships with Ferdinand and Caliban lie in the equality, or lack thereof, dynamic of the relationship. In Miranda's relationship with Ferdinand they are equal. Or as equal a man and woman in that time could be in a relationship. We can see this equality demonstrated in act three scene 1 when Miranda and Ferdinand are professing their love for each other."I had rather crack my sinews, break my back, than you should dishonour undergo While I sit lazy by. It would become me as well as it does you, I should do it". Miranda is saying how she would do whatever Ferdinand does, in order to prove her love for him. This shows how their is no notion of complete superiority over one another. In her relationship with Caliban however, Miranda looks down upon Caliban with scorn and pity. This is evidenced in act one scene 2 when we see the first on-stage interaction between the two. "Abhorred slave, Which any print of goodness wilt not take, being capable all ill! I pitied thee," (1.2 351-353,Miranda) Miranda is demonstrating a sense of dominance and superiority over Caliban, by de-humnazing him. This is a very good example of a ruler-subject relationship, as well as an example of the relationship between conqueror, and indigenous population. - Johnnycakes
(1) Ferdinand's intentions to keep faithful to Miranda are much different than Caliban's to keep faithful to Stephano and Triniculo. Ferdinands desire to keep Miranda safe is driven by his love for her. Ferdinand would rather carry logs and have his back strained than to harm her. "No my precious creature, I'd rather crack my sinews, break my back. Then should such dishonor undergo while I sit lazy by" (3.1 26-28) Caliban, however, has a sole purpose to defeat Prospero. He is so excited to get out of his bond to Prospero that he quickly sells himself over to someone else. Ferdinand's pledge may be forever, but it is likely that Caliban's will one day fade.
--FrankenCakes
The relationship between Caliban and Miranda is different then that of Miranda and Ferdinand because in the relationship of Miranda and Caliban, Caliban sees Miranda as an object rather than a person with feelings. Ferdinand truly loves Miranda and would do anything to help her. His love for Miranda is natural whereas Caliban doesn’t truly respect Miranda, as it is said that Caliban tried to rape her. However, we can not come to a conclusion that Ferdinand might actually be in love with Miranda because a spell has been cast upon him; however Caliban, it seems, is truly in love with her; but for reasons under than her personality - Patrick
The masque was supposed to be a show to Ferdinand and Miranda that love has its thrills in the beginning, but then soon afterwards it loses its excitement. Just as the Masque was very exciting when it was being set up, it lost all of its excitement once Prospero made it disappear. "These our actors,
As I foretold you, were all spirits and
Are melted into air, into thin air:
And, like the baseless fabric of this vision,
The cloud-capp'd towers, the gorgeous palaces,
The solemn temples, the great globe itself,
Ye all which it inherit, shall dissolve" (4.1.148-154) Prospero is making this a metaphor to their Ferdinand and Miranda's love.
-Albert
Prospero’s plays a very specific role in Miranda’s relationships with Ferdinand and Caliban. With Ferdinand, Prospero encourages her romantic relationship with him. It is all part of his master plan, and he needs to put Miranda in a position that is beneficial to him. By marrying Ferdinand, the heir of Naples, Miranda would eventually become queen, putting Prospero back in a position of power. Therefore, he encourages her to pursue a romantic relationship with Ferdinand. On the other hand, he looks upon Caliban as a servant. Because he is her only true family, Miranda completely trusts Prospero’s judgment, and if he treats Caliban harshly, she will most likely agree with it. Prospero uses Caliban to gain power over the island, and makes Caliban up to be a cruel, savage being. Miranda automatically looks at him like that, and when he attempts to rape her out of rage and want of revenge against her father, the idea is only enforced.
-Kate
Ferdinand's relationship with Miranda is very different from Caliban's relationship to Miranda in many ways. Caliban seems to like the idea of being with Miranda and her physical beauty more than he actually appreciates her. Caliban doesn't appear to have an actual bond with Miranda, whereas Ferdinand seems to love her personality and not only her looks. Ferdinand pledges to keep Miranda's honor safe for a few reasons. First of all Ferdinand has already worked very hard to win over Prospero and he does not wish to lose that approval now. Additionally, Ferdinand believes that Miranda is virtually perfect and he does not wish to lose her love over such a trifle matter.
-Mitchell
Mary I am very offended F Block doesn't have nicknames.
- Not a nickname
Caliban's relationship with Miranda is different than Ferdinand's. Caliban raped Miranda showing that he didn't respect her feelings while Ferdinand says he praises her sweet thoughts and gentleness in Act 3, Scene 1. He pledges to keep her honor safe by not taking her virginity.
- Caleb
Ferdinand is much different from Caliban in his relationship with Miranda in that it is not a one-way relationship. With Caliban and Miranda, she loathed him after his previous unknown violation of her. It also appears through the text that he may have only pretended to like her to learn her language and possibly to violate her (physically, verbally, it is unknown).
This, however, is not the case in Miranda's relationship with Prospero. Their love is seemingly endless, and each one is fully devoted to the other. Ferdinand expresses his affection towards Miranda, excaliming, "I, beyond all limit of what else i' th' world, do love, prize, honor you." (3.1. 72-3) Here you can see that Ferdinand truly cherishes Miranda, and would never cause harm to her, where as Caliban would use her for his own benefit.
However, there is obviously some doubt in Prospero of Ferdinand's truth. The other men from the ship have given a very negative impression, and Prospero fears for his daughter's well-being. He asks Ferdinand to pledge to keep her honor safe because he fears that Ferdinand would otherwise break that pledge. It is still unclear of Ferdinand's true character, but for Miranda's sake, I hope he turns out to be as kind as he appears.
-(that was) EZ
Caliban and Ferdinand are both keys to essential power. Prospero looks past his daughters emotions and only considers the outcome on his part. If Miranda marries Ferdinand, she will eventually become queen therefor giving Prospero power. On the other hand, Caliban has all the secrets to the island. Even though he has harassed Miranda, Prospero will do anything to be as powerful as possible. Prospero tries to show that every choice he makes is going to be best for his daughter. Even though his attempts to cover up his selfishness are mostly successful, Miranda is bound to catch on. Her realtionship with Caliban is more of Master-Servant, where as Ferdiand's is full of compassion. These two choices do affect Prospero's want for power, but the decision will also help shape the readers perspective of what Miranda's true views are.
-Chloë
The difference between Miranda and Caliban and Miranda and Ferdinand lie in which man Miranda likes back. Miranda is completely in love with Ferdinand but not with Caliban. Both Caliban and Ferdinand like Miranda but only Ferdinand has a chance. Ferdinand pledges to keep her safe because Caliban is a threat to their relationship because he tried to rape her before. Also I think that Ferdinand pledges his love because he is threatened by Prospero and wants to prove to him that he will protect his daughter.
-Ally
Ferdinand and Caliban both have very different relationships with Miranda. Ferdinand is deeply in love with Miranda for who she is and Caliban likes her for her looks and access to power. Ferdinand truly likes her for her and Caliban just wants to use her as an advantage for himself. By marrying Miranda, Caliban would not only gain a perfect wife but also more power, which is exactly what he wants. Also, Miranda is in love with Ferdinand, not Caliban. Ferdinand’s relationship with Miranda is much more genuine than Caliban’s.
-Hannah Hylton
The difference between Caliban and Ferdinand's is the power. Even though Prospero may love his daughter he cares more for the power. He lost it to his brother before because he focused on his studies not on his role as duke. Prospero is still upset by him being banished from his home so what he has planed is to marry Miranda of to Ferdinand. However he is stuck between Ferdinand and Caliban because Ferdinand can make Miranda a Queen and Caliban knows all the secrets to the island. HE hasn't once asked his DAUGHTER what she wants all he wants is revenge but what he wants the most is POWER! SO Prospero is know just trying to figure out which one will give him the most power so he can show it of to everyone. --Chely
Prospero throws an exquisite masque to demonstrate his power, as well as his deep desire for Ferdinand and Miranda to consummate their marriage before intimacy. The impact of this lavish masque on Ferdinand and Miranda is a complete understanding of Prospero’s request. Prospero is counting on the desires of the young couple to push them into a quick marriage. His hope is this will accelerate his return to power through his relations to Ferdinand and his royal bloodline. Prospero uses this marriage to benefit himself. Manipulating, and not truly honoring the sanctity of the marriage bond. The message rebutting the importance to consummate marriage before intimacy.
-Aislinn
Ferdinand is different from Caliban in his relationship with Miranda because he fell in love with her on first sight; most likely meaning the attraction was mostly physical based. Although this is the case, his love seems to be much more genuine then that of Caliban. Caliban and Miranda’s relationship was more for beneficial aspects then that of love. Miranda taught him language while Caliban did her chores and this amicable relationship only changed when Caliban took advantages of her. Ferdinand pledges to keep her honor save because the last time she put her trust into a man (Caliban) it didn’t turn out very well. Ferdinand is pledging that he will not only keep her save, but also treat her as an equal.- Trevor
Post a Comment